o


Patrick Mahomes is a better quarterback than Tom Brady......I would takes Patrick Mahomes over Tom Brady 10 times out of 10.

If I had a choice between Patrick Mahomes, Dan Marino, and Peyton Manning, I would have to think about it......but I would take any one of those 3 over Tom Brady.

o

One stat you failed to mention is tainted seasons due to the player and/or his team cheating. Brady easily leads in that category at 9+ seasons to 0 for Manning.

This is incorrect as KC already had their possession. If we had scored a TD we would have won.

It's super retarded since if we score a TD the game's over. This is pretty similar to when SS went super conservative last year vs. the Donks when we got to within ~60 yard FG range. Only then we were bailed out by the Donks ST penalty.

Jeff Saturday

Which one would you take with those Patriot defenses. Marino would have slaughtered teams. Peyton would have kept his defenses fresh with long possessions.

Manning was the best QB period. He wasn't on the best teams, unfortunately, but he was the best QB to ever play the game.

He had 23 seasons to Manning's 17, OF COURSE he should have better counting stats than Manning. Manning kills him on a per game basis, however, and again, Manning won 5 MVPs in 17 NFL seasons, Brady won 3 in 23. This is a no brainer if you look past the very surface of the numbers.

I wouldn't say he kills him, Here are some per game stats

Manning 270 ypg. 2 TD per game
Brady 266 ypg 1.9 TD per game

However, Manning does kill Brady in total interceptions

Manning 251 - 27 of which were pick sixes
Brady 212 - 13 of which were pick sixes

This is a fun argument you guys are having. My own opinion is that there is no one QB who historically just stands head and shoulders above everyone else. Everyone thinks the greatest of all time was a player they watched, 40 years from now neither Brady or Maning will be the GOAT for those fans, it will be somebody not even born yet. Having said that Brady and Manning played in the same era and in my opinion Manning was way better than Brady at their peak. Without Manning the Colts were mediocre, without Brady the Patriots were still contenders.

You're correct, there are differing opinions on the subject, fans of their favorite team want their QB to be the GOAT

There are some who say Otto Graham was the GOAT
There are some who say Unitas was the GOAT
There are some who say Montana was the GOAT
There are some who say Marino was the GOAT
There are some who say Elway was the GOAT
There are some who say Manning was the GOAT
There are some who say Mahomes is the GOAT

But most say Brady was the GOAT

I do agree, in the regular season, Manning was the best, but in the playoffs, he was not.